Spiritual Leadership – What is it? Pros/Cons? Examples?


The leadership theories we’ve discussed have neglected one crucial component. It’s often something we tend to ignore as we become absorbed with completing performance targets and saving the organization’s bottom line.

This component is altruistic love, a term coined by Pitirim Sorokin. As the founder of the Harvard Research Center in Creative Altruism, Sorokin believed that altruistic love extends beyond religious rituals. Instead, altruistic love is unselfish love based on the foundation of benevolence.

Shifting the focus to altruistic love helps leaders appreciate that their teams want to do work they find meaningful, work that makes a difference. This thinking can improve the team’s intrinsic motivation and productivity.

However, there is much more to spiritual leadership than altruistic love. Read this article to find out what spiritual leadership is all about.

What is Spiritual Leadership?

Louis Fry developed the concept of spiritual leadership in the early 2000s as a part of the intrinsic leadership theory. He explained the need for spiritual leadership in a 2008 journal article[1] entitled Spiritual Leadership: State-of-the-Art and Future Directions for Theory, Research, and Practice. Two justifications for spiritual leadership are presented in the article:

  • Businesses are responding to global changes with a growing sense of spiritual consciousness
  • Employees are actively looking for meaningful work experiences

Fry further states that these justifications led to an understanding of workplace spirituality. He cites the following definition from Giacalone and Jurkiewicz

[Workplace spirituality is] a framework of organizational values evidenced in the culture that promotes the employees’ experience of transcendence through the work process, facilitating their sense of being connected in a way that provides feelings of compassion and joy.

Workplace spirituality then forms the core of the spiritual leadership’s three defining features:

  1. Vision
  2. Hope/Faith
  3. Altruistic love

What Are the Fundamentals of Spiritual Leadership?

Spiritual leadership builds on three fundamentals, namely Vision, Hope/Faith and Altruistic Love. Each of them are described in more detail below this summary image.

Feel free to use this image as long as you link back to this page.

Vision

Employees should believe that the company’s vision provides a meaningful future. Instead of focusing on the drudgery of completing routine tasks, employees will be inspired to play their part in achieving something that matters. The vision, therefore, should have broad appeal, clearly describe the final destination and the steps the organization will take to get there, and encourage hope and faith. There are some similarities with visionary leadership here. Refer to this article for more information on that: visionary leadership.

Hope/Faith

Leaders should be confident that the team is able to achieve the vision. This represents the hope/faith necessary to inspire the team to make the vision a reality and gives employees a sense that their life has meaning.

Hope and faith also give the motivation to press forward towards the vision despite the challenges that arise. Therefore, it’s a two-pronged element that involves being inspired by a meaningful vision and using that inspiration as the primary motivation to keep moving forward.

Altruistic Love

Employees expect leaders to display mutual care and respect for all members of the organization. This altruistic love is based on fundamental values that the team accepts to be morally right and that are modeled by spiritual leaders in their attitudes and behavior.

These characteristics of spiritual leadership make it a valuable leadership style for supporting an organization’s triple bottom line – people, planet and profit.

Spiritual leadership can also be viewed from two perspectives – personal and organizational. The personal perspective highlights inner life as its source where organizations recognize the spiritual needs of each employee. It also emphasizes personal spiritual leadership where the leader’s development is based on individual knowledge, the skills required for the role and how the leader is able to impact followers to move in a particular direction.

The organizational perspective focuses on how everyone in the organization can work together to achieve meaningful objectives. The leader in this case is anyone within the organization who has a positive influence on the team’s calling, membership and performance. It allows for both formal and informal leaders to play a role in the organization’s development.

This strong focus on the team members and their well being is similar to Affiliative leadership, the link takes you to our detailed article on that leadership style.

What are the Pros and Cons of Spiritual Leadership?

Like all leadership styles, Spiritual leadership also has its advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages of Spiritual Leadership

1. Everyone feels like they belong

Spiritual leadership helps create a sense of belonging. This brings a sense of security and satisfaction which motivates employees to be productive. It also reduces the employee turnover right thus saving the organization from overspending on constantly hiring new employees.

2. Individuals are recognized for the work they do

Altruistic love creates room for individual recognition. A spiritual leader wants everyone to feel appreciated and will, therefore, put out the effort to recognize employees for their efforts.

3. Employee health can improve

It is believed that spiritual leadership can have a positive impact on people’s mental health and general life satisfaction. This in turn leads to a positive impact on physical health.

4. Corporate social responsibility is an important organizational objective

Altruistic love extends beyond the workplace and into the communities an organization serves. Emphasis on spiritual leadership ultimately leads to a greater focus on corporate social responsibility. Therefore, the organization will be more deliberate in supporting the needs of the community through environmental projects, volunteering in social projects and giving back in other ways deemed relevant.

Disadvantages of Spiritual Leadership

1. Religious beliefs may seep in with this leadership style

Although spiritual leadership in the workplace isn’t necessarily based on religious beliefs, it is possible for some spiritual leaders to use their religious beliefs as a guide for the way they act. There is nothing inherently wrong with this until it becomes a case of the leader forcing his or her religious beliefs on employees. It is better for mutual respect for all employees’ religions to prevail in the workplace.

2. Loss of focus on business objectives

The spiritual feeling and focus might receive too much focus resulting in organizational and business targets being neglected as a consequence. The spiritual leader needs to balance well-being with performance and progress accordingly.

3. Too nice an environment

Just like in affiliative leadership, there is a risk that conflicts and feedback are swept under the rug in order to not disrupt the feeling of harmony in the team. This would result in unresolved issues which can grow and fester over time, leading to bitterness and resentment within the team.

4. Non-spiritual people might not fit in

Not everybody is spiritual. The high focus on spiritual areas can make others feel left out or shut out by the others. Despite a strong spiritual orientation in an organization, there might still be need for individuals who simply aren’t willing to participate in the spiritual side of things. A spiritual leader needs to make everybody feel welcome and part of the organization, even when it comes to non-spiritual people.

How Can You Be an Effective Spiritual Leader?

These are the skills you will need to develop if you want to become an effective spiritual leader.

Self Awareness

Spiritual leaders have high emotional intelligence. They understand their emotions and the emotions of others and can readily adjust their actions to prevent emotional conflicts with their team. Achieving this level of emotional intelligence requires paying attention to constructive criticism, observing the attitudes and behaviors of those around you, and continuous introspection. Read our article on empathy for additional tips.

Effective Communication

Each element of spiritual leadership depends heavily on the leader’s ability to effectively communicate. Gina Smith, Maria Minor and Henry Brashen state that “effective communicators understand how to inspire a shared vision, challenge processes, enable others to act, and encourage the heart. Spiritual leaders are effective communicators since they must actively listen, clearly deliver ideas and motivate.”[2]  

Promote Healthy Conflict

Spiritual leadership thrives in a work environment where openness is encouraged. It is important for everyone to be open and honest so that issues can be swiftly addressed, and healthy conflict can be encouraged.

When does Spiritual Leadership Work Best?

Spiritual leadership is good for organizations where there is low employee morale and high tension. An effective spiritual leader can transform the work environment into one that is positive and conducive to the development of a strong team.

Furthermore, the spiritual leadership style can be very useful in environments where cause is of greater importance than in the average organization. Nonprofit organizations and environmental organizations as well as others with an overarching cause might benefit from spiritual leadership.

Who Are Some Examples of Spiritual Leaders?

Barry Garapedian – Managing Director at Morgan Stanley

Barry Garapedian is one of the most well-known spiritual leaders in business[3]. His altruistic love is evident in how he approaches the holistic development of his employees; he encourages them to take time for their relationships, physical health and spiritual well-being. Employees are then more motivated to be productive and help the organization meet its wealth creation objectives for clients.

This approach to leadership has helped him create a company that consistently receives high ratings for employee satisfaction, employee commitment, customer trust, community service and wealth creation. Additionally, he uses an L-form (learning organization) spiritual leadership model where member engagement is paramount and all employees are encouraged to take part in learning, experimentation and continuous improvement.

Julie Weber – Vice President and Chief People Officer at Southwest Airlines

In her role as Chief People Officer, Julie Weber has adopted a “hiring for attitude” motto for attracting the right talent to the company. Anyone hired by the company must display courage, perseverance, innovation and a willingness to put others first. Their aim is to hire people who are already engaged and have values that align with those of the organization.

One of the strategies Weber and her team uses to recognize employees who display the right values is the Winning Spirit Recognition program. According to Weber[4], this program “recognizes employees who deliver exceptional Southwest hospitality, display tremendous acts of courage, demonstrate outstanding teamwork, show heartfelt compassion or volunteer in their communities.”

Therefore, it’s not surprising that Southwest has a 4.5 star rating on TripAdvisor. Employees are clear about the organization’s values and vision and do their best to make that vision a reality.

References

http://what-when-how.com/love-in-world-religions/altruistic-love/
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02627/full#B28
https://iispiritualleadership.com/spiritual-leadership/#3


[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304736788_Spiritual_Leadership_State-of-the-Art_and_Future_Directions_for_Theory_Research_and_Practice
[2] https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1188325.pdf
[3] https://gbr.pepperdine.edu/2017/12/spiritual-leadership-learning-organization/
[4] https://www.thehrdigest.com/southwest-airlines-julie-weber-on-what-it-means-to-create-a-purpose-driven-culture/

Carl Lindberg

Carl is a global business leader that has led 1-2000 people and had financial responsibility of 200-500 MUSD. During his career, he has led employees in twenty different countries and has lived in three continents.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Content